Rare Fort Myers Investment & Development Opportunity! Two adjacent residential properties are being offered together (5442 Fourth Ave), creating an excellent opportunity for an investor, developer, or owner-user. The property includes a vacant, undeveloped duplex lot that is easy to clear, plus an adjacent single-family property featuring a livable 3-bedroom, 1-bath home.
The single-family residence has been updated with a new roof, impact windows, and fresh interior/exterior paint. The home needs some additional work but is otherwise livable and offers immediate potential. A large 15′ x 20′ storage shed is located in the rear yard, providing substantial additional storage space.
The adjacent duplex lot is currently undeveloped, offering a clean slate for future development. Potential exists to combine the two lots into one parcel and pursue rezoning to allow for a multifamily development, subject to City/County approval and applicable zoning and land-use requirements. Total combined acreage over 12,000 sqft.
Conveniently located near Downtown Fort Myers, shopping, dining, major roads, and other amenities, this property offers both current residential use and significant future development potential. An excellent opportunity to acquire two adjoining properties with multiple possibilities for redevelopment, investment, or an owner-user strategy.
The single-family residence has been updated with a new roof, impact windows, and fresh interior/exterior paint. The home needs some additional work but is otherwise livable and offers immediate potential. A large 15′ x 20′ storage shed is located in the rear yard, providing substantial additional storage space.
The adjacent duplex lot is currently undeveloped, offering a clean slate for future development. Potential exists to combine the two lots into one parcel and pursue rezoning to allow for a multifamily development, subject to City/County approval and applicable zoning and land-use requirements. Total combined acreage over 12,000 sqft.
Conveniently located near Downtown Fort Myers, shopping, dining, major roads, and other amenities, this property offers both current residential use and significant future development potential. An excellent opportunity to acquire two adjoining properties with multiple possibilities for redevelopment, investment, or an owner-user strategy.
Property Details
Price:
$245,000
MLS #:
A12077958
Status:
Active
Beds:
0
Baths:
0
Type:
Single Family
Subtype:
Residential
Subdivision:
Pine Manor
Neighborhood:
pinemanor
Listed Date:
Aug 26, 2026
Lot Size:
5,999 sqft / 0.28 acres (approx)
See this Listing
Schools
Interior
Exterior
Direction Faces
East
Fencing
Fenced
Lot Features
Fenced, No Misc/Improvements, Sidewalk
Other Structures
None
Financial
Tax Year
2025
Taxes
$197
Map
Community
- Address5438/5440 Fourth Ave Fort Myers FL
- SubdivisionPine Manor
- CityFort Myers
- CountyLee County
- Zip Code33907
Subdivisions in Fort Myers
- 00
- Alta Mar
- Avalon Bay Condo,Avalon Bay
- Bali Hai
- BARDEN
- Baypointe Yacht & Racquet
- BAYSHORE COMMONS
- BELLE AIRE LAGOON
- BLVD HTS SHOPPING CENTER
- BRIDGETOWN AT THE PLANTATI,Botanica Lakes
- Broadview Manor,PALM BEACH TO RIVER
- Buckingham
- Carver Park
- City View Park 03
- City View Park 03,Fort Myers
- COLONNADE AT THE FORUM
- CRANE LANDING
- Crane Laning Phaase III,Crane Laning Phaase
- CRANFORDS
- DAUGHTREYS CREEK
- Daughtreys Creek 1st Add
- DIXON PARK
- DONORA TO CONNECTICUT,Eucalyptus Park
- ESTERO PARK
- Florida Gulf Coast ZDD,Overiver Shores
- Forest Park
- FORSYTH RIVERVIEW
- FORT MYERS
- fort myers shore
- fort myers shores
- Gulf Waters RV Resort,Gulf Waters RV Resor
- HARBOR ESTATES
- HARBOR ESTATES FIRST ADD
- Harlem Lake
- HILLS T P
- Kelly Greens
- Lee County Unincorporated
- lehigh acres
- LEILANI
- LINDA LOMA
- Lovejoy Court
- Messina at Miromar Lakes,Miromar Lakes
- MIRROR LAKES
- MYSTIC GARDENS
- North Fort Myers
- Orange River Hills
- PARKWAY PRESERVE
- PARKWAY PRESERVE,Sobel Co.
- PINEWOOD SOUTH CONDO PH II
- Port Edison
- Province Park
- Riva Del Lago
- River Hall Country Club Ph,River Hall
- River Place
- ROYAL GREENS AT GATEWAY
- ROYAL WOODS
- Royal Woods Ph 02
- SCHOONER BAY CONDOMINIUM,SCHOONER BAY CONDOMI
- Seven Lakes
- Shannon Blvd
- SUNCOAST ESTATES
- TERRACE III AT RIVERWALK
- THE RESIDENCE
- The Residence Condominiums
- The South Half
- TRAVERS & HENDRYS,Hillcrest
- Village of Cedarbend
- WATER’S EDGE,WATER’S EDGE AT PEPP
- WATERWAY STATES
- Whiskey Creek Club Estates
- WHITEHEAD CREED
- Wildcat Farms
- Windsor West
Market Summary
Current real estate data for Single Family in Fort Myers as of Oct 26, 2026
46
Single Family Listed
173
Avg DOM
239
Avg $ / SqFt
$409,685
Avg List Price
Property Summary
- Located in the Pine Manor subdivision, 5438/5440 Fourth Ave Fort Myers FL is a Single Family for sale in Fort Myers, FL, 33907. It is listed for $245,000 and features 0 beds, 0 baths, and has approximately 0 square feet of living space.The average price per square foot for Single Family listings in Fort Myers is $239. The average listing price for Single Family in Fort Myers is $409,685. To schedule a showing of MLS#a12077958 at 5438/5440 Fourth Ave in Fort Myers, FL, contact your CENTURY 21 Carioti agent at 2392986550.
Similar Listings Nearby

5438/5440 Fourth Ave
Fort Myers, FL
